You have 15 minutes to make a decision that could affect your company for many years ahead.
What do you do?
The scenario: One of your best employees has been with the company for eight years. They are loyal, respected, and they know the business inside and out. Your department head is leaving in 60 days, and this employee wants the job. But there is a problem, they’re not quite ready. They demonstrate great problem-solving skills, but struggle to delegate effectively. They know the business well but never have had any real experience flying solo with a budget.
Do you:
A. Give them the job because they have earned it. They know the company, and you hope they can grow into the position.
B. Hire someone from the outside. The position is too important, and you need someone who has experience in this job, even if that means losing the loyal employee.
C. Promote them, but build a plan around them that includes coaching, mentoring and expectations. This, of course, requires extra time and resources but ensures you retain the employee.
Take a few minutes to think it over, then pick one. There is no right or wrong answer, but research gives a few things to consider that can help make that decision.
Don’t Become the Bottleneck
CEO’s lead the company, but that doesn’t mean they should be responsible for making every decision.
In a Harvard Business Review article, author Nitin Nohria argues that the CEO’s most important job is shaping how decisions are made but not personally making them. If every question lands on the CEO’s desk, he or she hasn’t built a company that could operate without him or her. Instead, it is a business that pays employees to depend on one person to keep things moving and growing.
You have 60 days before your department head leaves. That is enough time to allow the prospective leader to make some decisions. Let them make the call and then watch what happens. You aren’t looking for perfection. You are looking for good judgment.
Don’t Just Hope for the Best
If you choose C, follow through.
In McKinsey & Company’s report, “Three Keys to Faster, Better Decisions,” researchers found that organizations were more likely to report more effective, better decisions when employees were given decision-making authority and the proper coaching.
Instead of congratulating someone on the promotion and offering an open-door policy if they have a question, be proactive in developing a strong support plan. Responsibility should never come without some type of good support behind it.
To Retain or Not Retain?
One of the most common reasons that weak spots are created in the organizational chart is because someone was afraid of losing someone else. So, although the CEO had reservations, the promotion was granted because the CEO didn’t want the employee to leave.
If leaders want to keep good employees but those employees are not actually ready for the job, there are other ways they can help develop them. Give them feedback and analyze how they respond. Be honest about the reservations. Most employees want to know where their strengths and weaknesses are. Those conversations matter because they show employees you are paying attention to them and are willing to help them achieve more with the company.
Ask the Hard Questions
If a CEO finds himself or herself in this situation more than once, it begs the question, “Why aren’t these people ready?”
Somewhere along the line, the employees are not developing, and it is important to find out why and who is responsible for that. It may be an uncomfortable look within for a leader, but it certainly is worth it. In fact, one Deloitte report notes that only about one-third of CEOs feel as though their companies had a strong pipeline of viable future CEO candidates. Even if a company has a succession plan in place, if there are not enough people ready to fill the jobs, it’s a problem.
The answer could be some changes in how the CEO is leading now to ensure that he or she is doing everything they can to encourage growth and development among the most promising employees.
So, what would you do: A, B or C?
Again, there is no universal choice, but there is a bigger question that should serve as the foundation for any decision:
If you couldn’t come to work tomorrow, how much of your company would still work? That’s the real test.